Grand Haven recommends $59.2M environmental plan to cap, contain coal ash on Harbor Island
City officials in Grand Haven have released a long-awaited environmental study detailing five options to clean up toxic coal ash and industrial chemicals on Harbor Island, recommending a $59.2 million plan that leaves the majority of the contamination contained on-site rather than hauling it away.
GRAND HAVEN — City officials in Grand Haven have released a long-awaited environmental study detailing five options to clean up toxic coal ash and industrial chemicals on Harbor Island, recommending a $59.2 million plan that leaves the majority of the contamination contained on-site rather than hauling it away.
The 100-plus-page Remedial Alternatives Analysis, prepared by consulting firm HDR and published Tuesday, lays out the roadmap for addressing legacy pollution at the former J.B. Sims Generating Station, a coal-fired power plant that operated on the Grand River waterfront for decades.
Grand Haven officially ceased operations on February 20, 2020, and its main smokestack and powerhouse were demolished by implosion on Oct. 15, 2022.
The city’s preferred approach, dubbed Alternative 5, would excavate coal combustion residuals and contaminated soil from outer areas of the island and consolidate them into a smaller, 27-acre central containment zone. The site would then be enclosed by a subsurface barrier wall, capped with protective material, and managed with continuous groundwater extraction and treatment.
At $59,187,300, Alternative 5 is the cheapest of five proposals evaluated in the report. The most expensive option — a complete excavation and off-site disposal to a certified landfill — carries an estimated price tag of $86.2 million.
Derek Gajdos, project management director for the City of Grand Haven, said digging up all the waste and trucking it off the island carried severe environmental and financial trade-offs.
"The liabilities and cost significantly outweigh the benefits," Gajdos said in a public query response accompanying the report. "Safely removing the contamination and transporting it to a certified landfill presents significant risks to the environment, specifically the waterways and our community's drinking water source."
Gajdos noted that shipping waste off-site would leave the city indefinitely exposed to future environmental liabilities generated at third-party landfills.
Harbor Island has long been central to Grand Haven’s industrial past and its future waterfront planning. The study area contains coal combustion residuals — which can leach heavy metals like lithium into groundwater — as well as per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, known as PFAS.

City consultants evaluated options ranging from complete removal to full-site containment:
- Alternative 1 (Off-Site Excavation): Digs up and hauls away contaminated soil and ash to an off-site landfill for $86.2 million. It offers maximum redevelopment flexibility but carries the highest cost, heavy truck traffic, and excavation risks near the river.
- Alternative 2 (In-Situ Stabilization): Treats soil in place using Portland cement and carbon to solidify contaminants for $84.4 million. Long-term durability and effectiveness against PFAS remain uncertain.
- Alternative 3 (Full Containment): Encloses the entire contaminated footprint under a barrier wall and cap for $74.9 million. It creates the largest land use restrictions and the highest impact on local wetlands.
- Alternative 4 (Hybrid Containment): Combines targeted removal with a medium-sized containment area for $69.7 million.
- Alternative 5 (Reduced-Footprint Hybrid): Consolidates waste into a 27-acre footprint for $59.2 million, minimizing wetland disturbance while leaving the surrounding acreage open for potential public reuse.
Under Alternative 5, housing would be prohibited on the 27-acre capped mound, though shallow-rooted vegetation, turf, pavement, or solar panels could be built on top. Areas outside the cap could be opened to redevelopment, aligning with community feedback favoring parks, wildlife areas, and passive recreation.
City officials scheduled a public town hall to present the report 1-7 p.m. Dec. 1 at Central Park Place, 421 Columbus St.
The public meeting initiates a series of local reviews. The Parks and Recreation Commission and the Sustainability and Energy Commission are slated to discuss the plan in December, with the Board of Light and Power considering formal support on Dec. 17. The Grand Haven City Council is expected to vote on a resolution selecting the final remedy on Jan. 4, 2027.
If approved, official engineering plans will be submitted to the Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency around April 1, 2027.
Regulatory review is expected to take six to nine months, with construction potentially beginning between 2028 and 2030 depending on funding and permitting timelines.
— To submit a news tip, email newsroom@ottawanewsnetwork.org.