David Hoffman: Blind justice, not loyalty: Fixing a broken AG's office
"America deserves better than a federal legal system that believes its primary job is covering up the alleged crimes and abuses of powerful people," columnist David Hoffman writes.
EDITOR'S NOTE: The views and opinions expressed are those of the writer and not of Ottawa News Network.
In America’s adversarial legal system, criminal defense lawyers are often the most maligned professionals. This is because they frequently defend people accused of the most heinous acts.
But it is often forgotten that legal ethics require criminal defense attorneys to zealously represent the interests of their clients. By contrast, a prosecutor’s job is not to represent the interests of the governor or the president, but to pursue justice and not simply seek convictions at any cost. This is because prosecutors are the gatekeepers in the criminal justice system, meaning defense attorneys are often not needed unless charges have been brought.
One of the indicators of burgeoning authoritarianism is that competence and integrity are subordinate to loyalty and sycophancy, even though, as history has repeatedly shown, wannabe dictators rarely reciprocate such loyalty.
Many historians believe that the reason George Mason is considered a forgotten Founding Father is that he refused to sign the Constitution. Two concerns he had about the finished document were that it did not contain a Bill of Rights (which was added later) and that the presidential pardon power essentially gave presidents the ability to ignore, and even encourage, the criminality of their supporters, and pardon them if they were caught.
One of the reasons I became disillusioned with the practice of law is because of how politicized it actually was. Prosecutions, especially around election time, were frequently decided less on guilt or innocence and more on the political mileage they would bring.
Some pundits have pointed out that we are increasingly seeing this today, as critics of the current administration are often threatened with “investigations,” regardless of their innocence, while administration supporters are frequently not investigated, regardless of their guilt.
In other words, when the Justice Department, some federal judges and several Supreme Court “justices” believe their primary function is fabricating imaginary wrongdoing and/or covering up actual wrongdoing, based on an individual’s political persuasion or the whims of the president, then there isn’t any justice.
But don’t take my word for it.
Look at the facts.
There have been continuing questions surrounding the Justice Department's handling of the Jeffrey Epstein files, and several judges have also expressed doubts, based upon their courtroom experiences, about continuing to honor the department's historical presumption of honesty. In addition, a recent lawsuit filed by a former FBI leader in Chicago alleges that he was pressured into criminally charging a group of anti-ICE protesters, collectively known as the Broadview Six, whose charges were ultimately dismissed due to alleged prosecutorial misconduct.
Finally, in perhaps one of the most egregious examples of Justice Department weaponization, after six lawmakers released a video factually stating that military members have the right to disobey unlawful orders, attempts were made to criminally charge them. Had it not been for the fact that this required a grand jury indictment, which the department was unable to secure, the scheme might have succeeded.
In fact, it could be argued that since the Justice Department is now acting as Donald Trump’s private law firm, and several federal judges and Supreme Court justices now view themselves as Trump’s personal attorneys, perhaps a law should be passed that requires Trump, and not the taxpayers, to financially cover the costs of operating the Justice Department, FBI and courts where these judges and justices preside.
When one examines American history, it is not difficult to discern that many of the individuals who have occupied the office of U.S. attorney general — often called the highest law enforcement office in the nation — have been despicable human beings. This is why reforms must be implemented so this office is no longer guided or intimidated by presidential demands to circumvent justice and weaponize the legal system for political vendettas.
To accomplish this, this position must be filled by a nominating committee composed of judges and attorneys who submit at least five candidates that all federal judges, magistrates and Supreme Court justices will then vote on to decide who becomes attorney general. This will alleviate the naked partisanship that has, in the past, allowed incompetent and politicized people to achieve this office, and prevent the damage they do to its integrity.
While a natural criticism is that it is too unwieldy to do this every four years, this brings me to a second proposed reform. Attorneys general should serve a set term of 12 years. This would permit them to work under at least two presidential administrations and thus minimize obsequious loyalty to either one.
Finally, removal from the office of attorney general should only be accomplished if an official, independent disciplinary committee, in response to a complaint and subsequent investigation, recommends revoking an attorney general’s license to practice law. This would eliminate the pressure on attorneys general to succumb, under threat of being fired, to demands to engage in politically motivated prosecutions.
The point is that never again should a group of abuse victims watch helplessly as an attorney general refuses to acknowledge them or only agrees to meet with them to curry some political favor. Placing individuals into positions that empower them to take away people’s money, liberty and even their lives requires an independence and fairness that today’s system is incapable of producing.
America deserves better than a federal legal system that believes its primary job is covering up the alleged crimes and abuses of powerful people, while filing bogus or dubious charges against those who, in a supposedly free country, dare to criticize or even question these same powerful people.
Thomas Jefferson is quoted as saying, “I tremble for my country when I reflect that God is just.” I tremble because so many people being placed into positions of power are not.
— David R. Hoffman is a retired civil rights and constitutional law attorney.
How to submit an opinion
Ottawa News Network accepts columns and letters to the editor from everyone. Letters should be about 300 words and columns should not exceed 1,000 words. ONN reserves the right to fact-check submissions as well as edit for length, clarity and grammar. Please send submissions to newsroom@ottawanewsnetwork.org.